Time
S
Nick
Message
06:06 yoh joined #dataverse
06:50 axfelix joined #dataverse
07:01 bencomp joined #dataverse
07:01 bencomp left #dataverse
11:39 donsizemore joined #dataverse
11:39 donsizemore
@pdurbin was just about to send you Craig's dockerfiles but saw you linked them in #3938
11:42 andrewSC joined #dataverse
12:46 oscardssmith joined #dataverse
13:21 pdurbin
thanks
13:22 pdurbin
oscardssmith: here's the "gofmt for Java" thread: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/dataverse-dev/y2Jpk3szTf8/rckKmP6-BgAJ
13:22 pdurbin
What does everyone think about that thread?
13:23 pdurbin
mac_: welcome!
13:32 bjonnh
pdurbin: oh craig answer, brings things that may get things  going quicker
13:35 donsizemore joined #dataverse
13:47 pdurbin
oscardssmith: here's my writeup of keep, stop, and start from the community meeting retrospective: https://groups.google.com/d/msg/dataverse-community/gwnaDNE7LZU/Hji1P5eUAAAJ
13:48 pdurbin
we also do "kudos"
13:52 pdurbin
oscardssmith: here's a picture of my whiteboard: http://i.imgur.com/ulMnIbj.jpg
13:54 pdurbin
oscardssmith: here's my list of stuff to follow up with you on: https://trello.com/c/MQhQfWuE/1454-oscar-follow-up
14:40 pameyer joined #dataverse
14:44 pameyer
pdurbin , oscardsmith: I took a look at astyle, and looks like that might be able to get fairly close
14:44 pameyer
wasn't able to track down detailed info about what the netbeans java formatter default settings actually produce; but visually astyle seemed to get reasonably close
15:12 bjonnh
I looked at Chris's docker files
15:13 bjonnh
tbh the customization of dataverse is way beyond me
15:24 bjonnh
is it possible to use solr > 4.6.0 ?
15:25 bjonnh
pdurbin: ^?
15:25 bjonnh
I'm making a docker-compose to test the ndslabs dockers
15:25 pameyer
how much newer?
15:27 bjonnh
latest? :p
15:27 bjonnh
or 5.5
15:27 pameyer
I couldn't get 6.4.1 to work - that was the latest when I tried (a while back)
15:27 bjonnh
6.3 did work?
15:27 pameyer
I didn't try
15:28 bjonnh
what's the latest you tried and that worked?
15:28 pameyer
there was a point where the java API for solr changed
15:28 pameyer
4.6.0 was the last known-good version for me
15:28 bjonnh
ok
15:29 pameyer
the DV code would need to be updated for newer solr
15:29 pameyer
hopefully pdurbin can tell me if/where I'm wrong though
15:29 bjonnh
would it have to have backward compatibility?
15:29 pameyer
which "it"?
15:30 bjonnh
DV
15:30 bjonnh
would DV have to support older versions? or can it jump directly to latest?
15:31 pameyer
non-authoratatively, I'd guess it wouldn't need to support older solr versions
15:31 bjonnh
do we know to what extent DV users are customizing solr?
15:31 pameyer
my impression is not very much
15:40 oscardssmith joined #dataverse
15:47 pdurbin
bjonnh pameyer sorry, sorry, was at standup. let me catch up on the Docker comments at https://github.com/IQSS/dataverse/issues/3938
15:48 pameyer
pdurbin: np, that's where I'd figured you were
15:48 pdurbin
pameyer: we had standup in the Quantina for the first time
15:49 jhand joined #dataverse
15:50 pameyer
cool
16:07 pdurbin
bjonnh: we've only tested Solr 4.6.0 with Dataverse. I think I tried 4.6.10 once and it worked fine. I've never tried it with Solr 5 or 6. I assume you'd be interested in getting it working on the latest, which seems to be Solr 6.6.0.
16:10 pdurbin
bjonnh: as pameyer may recall, when making a custom metadata block, you must update the Solr schema. This has been observed at https://github.com/IQSS/dataverse/issues/3168
16:10 bjonnh
I would like it to work with anything that is a standard solr docker image
16:11 bjonnh
to avoid maintaining yet another image
16:11 pdurbin
that makes sense
16:12 pameyer
I'd forgotten about the solr schema updates
16:12 pdurbin
bjonnh: another case of someone messing with the Solr schema was changing "text_en" to "text_fr" at https://groups.google.com/d/msg/dataverse-community/9sjpBpPRuFk/0pamTkUiBgAJ
16:12 pdurbin
pameyer: it's like a bad dream, I bet. Cold sweats.
16:13 pameyer
my vague recollection was that that would be less work than necessary java changes...
16:13 pdurbin
yeah, and its semi-automated, at least
16:13 pdurbin
it's
16:15 bjonnh
again that's far beyond my skills…
16:21 pdurbin
bjonnh: do you want me to comment about anything specific in the github issue?
16:22 bjonnh
lets wait for my build based on 5
16:22 bjonnh
see if it works with 5
16:23 bjonnh
if not yes, we should probably make an issue to update scheme and whatever it implies in the code (I have no clue at all)
16:23 bjonnh
there are still the ndslabs way of having solr 4.6
16:23 bjonnh
s/are/is
16:23 bjonnh
so it is not blocking
16:24 pdurbin
not blocking is good
16:24 pdurbin
bjonnh: how long will the Docker image for Solr 5 be supported? Should we target Solr 6 instead?
16:29 bjonnh
oh yeah
16:29 bjonnh
but I wanted to try with 5 first
16:29 bjonnh
to know where things really changed
16:29 bjonnh
pameyer: tested 6 and it didn't work
16:30 bjonnh
so I'm going back in time
16:30 bjonnh
focus should be on the latest
16:30 bjonnh
I usually start coding with beta releases
16:30 bjonnh
as by the end of my dev, they will be out
16:31 pdurbin
bjonnh: I'm happy to re-open https://github.com/IQSS/dataverse/issues/456 once we have a little more information on which version of Solr we should target. Please feel free to leave a comment there.
19:07 oscardssmith joined #dataverse
22:19 pdurbin left #dataverse
